December 4, 2016 rss
header twitter link facebook link home link
View Resource Guide and Job Postings

Lawrence Glazer
Lawrence M. Glazer

Today’s Emergency Manager Law

January 17, 2013

Last year I wrote a piece contrasting the path a city would have to take under the State’s Emergency Manager statute vs. bankruptcy (“Trick Question for Detroit”, Feb. 16, 2012).

In the 2012 general election, the voters repealed that emergency manager statute by referendum. Then, in the last days of 2012, the lame duck legislature replaced the repealed statute with a new one: 2012 Public Act 346, the “Local Government and School District Fiscal Accountability Act”.

In signing the new bill into law, the governor said that it “builds in local control and options while also ensuring the tools to protect communities and school districts’ residents, students and taxpayers.”

But opponents have contended that the new law is just as undemocratic as the one it replaced, and have vowed to challenge it in court and at the ballot box.

So, who is right? Let’s take a look.

Both the repealed law and the new law apply to all municipalities (i.e., cities, villages, townships, etc) and public school districts. I will refer to them as “Locals”.

The process for determining that a local financial emergency exists is essentially the same as under the repealed law. A governor-appointed financial review team examines the Local’s finances and reports back to the governor, who makes the decision whether a “financial emergency” exists. The Local can appeal this determination to the Ingham County Circuit Court, just as it could under the repealed law.

Assuming that the determination is not overturned, the new law offers the Local a choice of four alternatives. This is new –at least on the surface. But the reality is that three of the four choices were available under the repealed law.

The four choices are:

  1. Appointment of an emergency manager. Of the seven emergency managers currently serving, only one (Muskegon Heights School District) was requested by the Local. The other six were imposed by the state, and it seems unlikely that very many Locals will seek an emergency manager voluntarily.
  2. Request permission to file for bankruptcy. This choice was also available under the repealed law if an emergency manager was appointed first. As far as I know, no Local has ever made this request and, again, it seems unlikely that any will.
  3. Negotiate a consent agreement. This process was also available under the repealed law, and the City of Detroit “chose” it, under pressure from the state.
  4. Neutral evaluation. This choice is new. The first step is that the Local and its creditors choose a mediator, called a “neutral evaluator”. The neutral evaluator has the duty of attempting to get the Local and its creditors to reach a settlement, but he or she cannot impose a settlement. The neutral evaluator also must explain “the limitations of Chapter 9 bankruptcy” to the parties, which I take to mean he or she must describe the endless litigation expense, time and uncertainties of municipal bankruptcy. The reason for this “explanation” requirement is made clear by what happens if the parties fail to settle: the Local must then request the governor’s permission to file for bankruptcy.

“Neutral evaluation” will put a lot of pressure on individual creditors to compromise on the debts owed by the Local. The choice presented to them will be “settle now for 50 cents on the dollar or pay your lawyer for a year of litigation and risk ending up with 20 cents on the dollar”.

The 2012 Act does give Locals more formal rights for input than the repealed law. The Local can terminate an emergency manager after twelve months by a 2/3 vote of its governing body, with concurrence of its elected executive, if there is one. But if it does this, the next step is mandatory neutral evaluation.

An emergency manager has the same power to change or terminate collective bargaining agreements that he or she had under the repealed law, with one difference. The emergency manager must submit the proposed action to the Local’s governing body, which has 17 days to approve or disapprove. If they disapprove, then they must submit an alternative plan “that would yield substantially the same financial result”. A governor-appointed state board then chooses either the emergency manager’s or the Local’s plan. The emergency manager then must implement whichever plan the state board chose.

So the bottom line is this: Locals do have more input than they did under the 2011 statute, but in all significant areas gubernatorial appointees still have the final say.

Opponents of the new law have at least two options: a ballot initiative and a court challenge.

The 2011 version of the emergency manager law was successfully challenged by ballot referendum; the opponents gathered signatures exceeding the Michigan Constitution’s requirement of at least 5 percent of the votes cast for governor in the preceding general election, which suspended the statute pending the next general election. In that election (2012) the “no” vote was higher than the “yes” vote, thus repealing the statute.

However, the opponents cannot use the referendum this time; the State Constitution prohibits a referendum if the statute includes an appropriation and 2012 PA 346 included two appropriations.

Instead, the opponents will have to use a different process, the ballot initiative. This requires submission of petitions with signatures exceeding 8 percent of all votes cast for governor in the preceding general election, which will increase the required signatures by almost 97,000.

A court challenge would probably take a year, maybe two years including appeals, and the result is impossible to predict. The opponents would argue that the legislature enacted a statute that is, in all significant respects, is the same as the statute which the voters repealed in the 2012 referendum. Supporters of the law would argue that the new statute is quite different not only in form, but in substance.

The courts would likely allow the law to continue in effect until all appeals were exhausted.

The Michigan Constitution contains no language expressly addressing this situation, but the obvious argument would be that the voters who approved the Constitution could not possibly have intended to allow the legislature to over-ride a referendum vote of the people.

So, one way or another, the new law will probably be with us for the foreseeable future.

Lawrence M. Glazer is the author of Wounded Warrior, a recently published biography of former governor and Supreme Court justice John Swainson. He is also a retired Ingham County Circuit Court Judge and former legal advisor to Gov. James J. Blanchard.

January 17, 2013 · Filed under Glazer

25 responses so far ↓

  • 1 Chuck May // Feb 25, 2013 at 8:51 pm

    Mr. Glazer, Im looking forward to reading your book on John B. Swainson, He holds a personal interest to me in that my father and he were high school buds and Army buds, as a matter of fact I have some letters from governor Swainson to my father, personal type..
    On another matter, would like your input into chance of challenging public act 38, 2011 and the courts opinion regarding age, the use of age classification, that is not unconstitutional per equal protection.. my challenge to this decision is the simple fact that (retiree pensioners are one and the same) and should be treated one and the same without regard to age. Yes, I am one of the group of babyboomers born in 1953, and therefore suffer the full financial tax burden, I retired from federal gov, in 2008 . I have read the Mi supreme court opinion, and can only say that it is self serving in nature and doesn’t treat my group of retiree the same as other retirees, when in fact we are all alike,, that is (retirees receiving a pension.) Any hope of successful legal challenge would seems to rely on how the state legislature used our age group in its classification of age. It appears arbitrary to use age in order to punish one group within the same group (retirees), and therefore by using the age
    characteristic it doesn’t make sense…

    your thoughts please

    Chuck May

  • 2 Lawrence Glazer // Mar 1, 2013 at 10:58 am

    Mr. May, thanks for your comment and question. In 2011 Gov. Snyder requested that the Michigan Supreme Court issue an advisory opinion regarding the constitutionality of 2011 PA 38. The Governor asked the Court to address four specific aspects of the statute, including whether the exemptions based on birth date were constitutional. The Court ruled:

    “we hold unanimously that:
    • Determining eligibility for income-tax exemptions on the basis of date of birth as set forth in MCL 206.30(9) does not violate the equal protection of the law under Const. 1963, art. 1, § 2 or the Fourteenth Amendment of the United States Constitution”

    That is the final word on it in Michigan. The only possibility of overturning the age -based tax exemption would be a suit in federal court, because the Michigan Supreme Court’s interpretation of the U.S. Constitution can be overturned by a federal court. I am not aware whether such a federal suit has been filed.

  • 3 Dau Design // Mar 5, 2014 at 6:04 pm

    428135 974528Glad to be one of several visitants on this incredible web website : D. 365974

  • 4 Waffeleisen Testsieger // Mar 5, 2014 at 6:14 pm

    654606 774335I conceive this web site contains some rattling fantastic info for everyone : D. 25325

  • 5 DS Domination Review // Mar 5, 2014 at 11:25 pm

    362329 12891Some genuinely superb blog posts on this website , regards for contribution. 245573

  • 6 Watch Video Here // Mar 8, 2014 at 8:16 am

    365252 191964This is a right blog for would like to find out about this topic. You realize a lot its almost challenging to argue along (not that I personally would want

  • 7 Quali sono i siti su cui si può trovare una buona scelta di batterie per moto? // Mar 8, 2014 at 9:29 am

    405618 546439You may uncover effective specific development of any L . a . Weight loss program and each and every you are really critical. To begin with level is an natural misplacing during the too considerably weight. shed belly fat 310332

  • 8 free slot play with bonus // Mar 10, 2014 at 2:14 pm

    405939 437020Hello! I could have sworn I

  • 9 full moving service // Mar 10, 2014 at 3:00 pm

    484668 560331Some truly howling function on behalf with the owner of this site , dead excellent topic matter. 586410

  • 10 free play slot machines // Mar 10, 2014 at 3:38 pm

    302456 97486Just a smiling visitor here to share the enjoy (:, btw excellent pattern . 721078

  • 11 hidemyass pro // Mar 10, 2014 at 11:34 pm

    you may have an amazing weblog correct here! would you prefer to make some invite posts on my weblog?

  • 12 photographer in az // Mar 12, 2014 at 8:40 pm

    443328 941461Hey there! Excellent post! Please when all could see a follow up! 101644

  • 13 Bolig til leie Alanya // Mar 13, 2014 at 4:08 am

    547418 541282 There is noticeably a bundle to know about this. I assume you produced certain good points in capabilities also. 666964

  • 14 hay day cheats // Mar 13, 2014 at 8:06 am

    Peace about the spiritual path is actually an awesome place, not to mention amazing start for the healing that one wants. When each of us gives our spiritual path/truth with somebody else, this makes our trip all the sweeter.

  • 15 starting your own blog // Mar 13, 2014 at 1:28 pm

    212960 688367I enjoy your writing style actually enjoying this internet web site . 78528

  • 16 lenticular imaging // Mar 13, 2014 at 8:43 pm

    556780 756557some genuinely choice content on this internet website , saved to my bookmarks . 748233

  • 17 how to build my own website // Mar 14, 2014 at 2:23 am

    456823 666925I like this site its a master peace ! Glad I located this on google . 564686

  • 18 Website // Mar 14, 2014 at 9:31 am

    great points altogether, you simply gained a new reader. What would you recommend in regards to your post that you made some days ago? Any positive?

  • 19 check this website // Mar 14, 2014 at 7:45 pm

    260496 957290I

  • 20 best glass screen protector // Mar 15, 2014 at 2:55 am

    887123 974969Read more on that great Post, I linked to you Thanks. 515405

  • 21 dead, deer, dead deer removal, dead animal removal nj, pick up dead animal nj, nj dead animal removal, dead animal pick up nj, dead deer removal nj, dead deer, dead animal nj, remove dead animal nj, remove dead animal new jersey, dead animal pick up new j // Mar 15, 2014 at 4:45 pm

    65151 463470Amaze! Thank you! I constantly wished to produce in my internet internet site a thing like that. Can I take element with the publish to my weblog? 563045

  • 22 Claude Rusak // Mar 16, 2014 at 5:54 am

    I am curious to find out what blog system you¡¯re working with? I¡¯m experiencing some minor security problems with my latest blog and I would like to find something more secure. Do you have any recommendations?

  • 23 Cockroach Control // Mar 17, 2014 at 5:35 am

    353198 637333Outstanding post, I conceive web site owners ought to learn a great deal from this blog its real user pleasant. 100916

  • 24 create a website // Mar 17, 2014 at 1:51 pm

    960975 551634if the buffalo in my head could speak german i would not know a god damm thing. What i do know is that the language of art is out of this world. 625536

  • 25 woningen // Mar 17, 2014 at 4:33 pm

    196980 750526It





© 2007-2011 All rights reserved. Site design by Kimberly Hopkins, khopdesign, llc.