April 26, 2018 rss
header twitter link facebook link home link
View Resource Guide and Job Postings

DC Image

Washington / Michigan

The Political Theater of Base Closings

by Sarah Kellogg
March 16, 2012

The painful and complex process used to close military bases in the United States is one of the rare moments in Washington where the rubber truly meets the road. If the government needs to shrink in size to balance the federal budget over the long term, then closing bases is an effective way of doing it.

But on Capitol Hill, the machinations around closing bases frequently turn into Kabuki theater as lawmakers and lobbyists employ any number of maneuvers, posturing and tricks to protect their turf from Pentagon budget-cutters looking to slash facilities and eliminate antiquated weapons system and staff to support them.

So, when Defense Secretary Leon Panetta announced in January that the Pentagon was considering employing two rounds of base closures, with reductions coming in fiscal years 2014 and 2017, to trim military spending, it caused a stir. The details were not known at the time, but the rumblings were felt at military installations around the nation.

Those rumblings became harsh reality in Michigan with the announcement of the first salvo—proposed reductions in force and aircraft from the U.S. Air Force for FY 2013. The Air Force said it planned to eliminate a quarter of Michigan’s Air National Guard staff. Some 850 full-time and part-time jobs would be lost if proposed cuts at Selfridge Air National Guard Base in Harrison Township and W. K. Kellogg Airport Air National Guard Station in Battle Creek were approved.

The reductions are the result, in part, of Pentagon plans to shift 24 A-10 fighter planes from Selfridge to other states, and a proposal to eliminate the older C-27J cargo aircraft from the fleet. Some of those airplanes are housed and serviced at Kellogg.

The response from Michigan’s congressional delegation was swift and pointed. Members questioned why the Air National Guard nationwide was bearing 59 percent of the Air Force’s cuts even though it represented only 6 percent of its budget costs. “At a minimum, we believe that a delay in any decision be made until the studies currently under way are completed to fully understand the delicate balance between cost savings and the preservation of combat capabilities,” wrote the 15 members of the delegation to congressional leaders.

Of course, Michigan has an ace in the hole here. U.S. Sen. Carl Levin (D-Detroit) is chairman of the powerful Senate Armed Services Committee which has oversight of the Pentagon’s budget. He will be a mighty obstacle to stripping airplanes from Michigan and closing bases down the road. He has already scheduled a hearing to quiz officials on why they targeted the Air National Guard for reductions.

One of the issues Levin is likely to bring up at the March 20 hearing is what the Pentagon is doing about closing bases overseas, especially those in Europe, which are beginning to seem so last century. Already the Obama administration has said it is shifting its military focus to Asia, and it seems unnecessary to keep some of the European bases open to protect our allies from our other allies.

Meanwhile Gov. Rick Snyder has joined with other governors to challenge the proposed 2013 cuts, as has Maj. Gen. Gregory Vadnais, commander of the Michigan National Guard. He signed onto a letter from 54 adjutant generals to the Pentagon opposing the reductions.

Many believe it is essential the states draw a bright yellow line early in the process because the results of these FY 2013 conflicts could determine the later base-closing recommendations. For example, eliminating the C-27J will leave Kellogg with no manned aircraft on its base. It will, however, become a home to the Air Force’s MQ-1 and MQ-9 unmanned aircraft. But that isn’t much to hang your hat on in a pitched battle over resources.

Much is at stake in Michigan in the coming skirmish over bases, especially the loss of thousands of jobs and millions of dollars in local investment every year. Michigan has felt the pain of this loss acutely in the past. The Pentagon closed Kincheloe (also known as Kinross) Air Force Base in Chippewa County in 1977, Wurtsmith Air Force Base in Iosco County in 1993, K.I. Sawyer Air Force Base in Marquette County in 1995 and the Detroit Arsenal Tank Plant in Warren in 1996, although a portion of the site is an active Army facility dedicated to tank research and development. In 2005, Michigan also lost jobs at Kellogg (they were transferred to Selfridge), the Navy Reserve Center in Marquette and the Parisan U.S. Army Reserve Center in Lansing.

When Panetta raised the specter of the base closing process, it was with the knowledge that it works, despite the local complaints and suffering. “I’ve been through BRAC,” Panetta said in January, referring to the Base Realignment and Closure Commission. “I know its weaknesses and its failings. Obviously we will continue to work to make sure it’s done effectively and that we achieve the savings we hope to achieve from the process. But I have to tell you, there is no more effective process to make it happen than using the BRAC process.”

When it comes, Michigan won’t feel the pain of base closings as much as states in the South or the West, mostly because it doesn’t have as much to lose. The state ranks a dismal 43rd out of 50 in its per capita defense spending. Still the threat of another round or two of base closures is serious. Michigan is a prime target because its forces have shrunk so significantly that consolidating them into other states makes good sense in terms of budgeting if not politics.

Certainly, members of the delegation will argue the need to fortify our forces in a world where the threats are numerous and complex, and that Michigan’s Air National Guard has been invaluable in Iraq and Afghanistan and should be rewarded, not penalized, for its service.

Inevitably, Michigan’s congressional delegation will be asked whether a streamlined Pentagon —and a federal budget much in need of balancing— can afford for Michigan to play a larger role in the military of the 21st century; a tough question to answer for the delegation’s deficit hawks. If the answer is no and Michigan were to lose both Selfridge and Kellogg, the state’s military activities could be reduced to more limited National Guard operations at the Alpena Air National Guard Base, Camp Grayling and Fort Custer Army National Guard Base, as well as recruitment and cemetery operations. Hopefully, the state could also keep its tank research and development work and defense logistics operations at the Hart-Dole-Inouye Federal Center in Battle Creek.

This reduced contribution is a mere shadow of the role Michigan played during World War II and the Cold War. But times inevitably change. Even with a smaller military presence, Michigan could still meaningfully support the military effort and the members of the U.S. Armed Forces.

Sarah Kellogg covered the Michigan congressional delegation and the federal government as the chief Washington correspondent for Booth Newspapers for 14 years. Before joining the Washington Bureau, Sarah covered state politics and government in the Booth Newspapers Lansing Bureau and directed Lansing coverage for United Press International. She helped launch MIRS’ Capitol Capsule, and served as its first writer and editor. A regular Dome columnist, she currently works as a freelance writer and editor for regional and national publications.

March 15, 2012 · Filed under DC Tags: , , ,

27 responses so far ↓

  • 1 Richard McLellan // Aug 2, 2013 at 11:52 am

    In the last two years, I have visited several military facilities as a member of the Defense Orientation Conference Association (DOCA). In talks with senior military officers, they overwhelmingly think there are too many bases and that the military would be stronger with fewer, better bases. The military is not a local jobs program and we should focus on the primary mission, providing a strong defense.

  • 2 microfit solar in ontario // Mar 7, 2014 at 6:50 pm

    512224 795192I discovered your internet site internet site online and check a lot of of your early posts. Maintain on the top notch operate. I just now additional your Feed to my MSN News Reader. Seeking for forward to reading considerably far more from you obtaining out later on!

  • 3 Qualcuno sa dove posso trovare batterie ricaricabili online? // Mar 8, 2014 at 9:57 am

    511296 947040Only a smiling visitant here to share the adore (:, btw fantastic design and style . 291759

  • 4 Su quale sito posso trovare informazioni su batterie per apparecchi acustici? // Mar 8, 2014 at 10:46 am

    413654 660084Yay google is my king aided me to discover this outstanding website! . 555349

  • 5 play online slots free // Mar 10, 2014 at 11:54 am

    161564 225899Cool text dude, keep up the great work, just shared this with the mates 89809

  • 6 washington classifieds // Mar 10, 2014 at 12:31 pm

    366021 937685Outstanding post, I feel weblog owners really should larn a good deal from this internet site its rattling user friendly . 119742

  • 7 Try this website // Mar 10, 2014 at 12:32 pm

    948868 164280I enjoyed reading your pleasant website. I see you offer priceless info. stumbled into this website by chance but I

  • 8 free slots no download // Mar 10, 2014 at 1:22 pm

    858037 764504Thrilled you desire sensible business online guidelines keep wearing starting tools suitable for the particular web-based business. cash 641089

  • 9 play free online slot machines no download // Mar 10, 2014 at 2:20 pm

    817447 247915Excellent humans speeches and toasts, possibly toasts. are hands down transferred at some time by means of party and expected to turn into really funny, amusing not to mention educational within the mean time. finest man wedding speeches 951771

  • 10 learn more here // Mar 10, 2014 at 7:24 pm

    992569 673348Considerably, the story is in reality the greatest on this noteworthy topic. I agree together with your conclusions and will eagerly watch forward to your next updates. Saying nice one will not just be sufficient, for the fantastic clarity inside your writing. I will immediately grab your rss feed to stay privy of any updates! 51810

  • 11 Hidemyass Pro // Mar 12, 2014 at 5:02 am

    I work here generic accutane (1) The University will release information without your prior consent to teachers, officials and

  • 12 turbulence training workout plan // Mar 12, 2014 at 9:15 am

    388138 348008Woh Everybody loves you , bookmarked ! My partner and i take problem inside your last point. 522989

  • 13 turbulence training review // Mar 12, 2014 at 10:26 am

    698360 430397This Los angeles Weight Loss diet happens to be an low and flexible going on a diet application meant for generally trying to drop the weight as well within the have a much healthier lifetime. lose weight 551736

  • 14 Visit This Link // Mar 13, 2014 at 11:34 am

    One thing I have actually noticed is that there are plenty of common myths regarding the financial institutions intentions while talking about foreclosures. One fable in particular is the bank prefers to have your house. The lending company wants your hard earned money, not your own home. They want the amount of money they loaned you having interest. Keeping away from the bank will undoubtedly draw the foreclosed final result. Thanks for your publication.

  • 15 Make money online // Mar 13, 2014 at 5:38 pm

    321284 931209Music started playing any time I opened this site, so irritating! 760672

  • 16 how to make my own website // Mar 14, 2014 at 1:03 am

    678092 829645You developed some decent points there. I looked over the internet for your issue and discovered most people will go along with together with your website. 825755



© 2007-2011 DomeMagazine.com. All rights reserved. Site design by Kimberly Hopkins, khopdesign, llc.