Put State’s Budget Surplus to Work

By on January 12th, 2012

Maxine Berman
John Austin

Put State’s Budget Surplus to Work

January 13, 2012
The New Year brought Michigan good news: U of M and MSU won bowl games; Michigan’s manufacturing economy is leading the nation’s economic rebound; and, lo and behold, a state budget surplus emerges — realistically in the $400 million range. It is important, as the governor polishes his State of the State Address and the legislature reconvenes, to put the money where it matters most to drive Michigan’s economy.
I applaud Governor Snyder for leading tough changes in 2011 to honestly stabilize Michigan’s fiscal situation, simplify the tax structure, and drive reforms in state and local government services. And Michigan probably needs to go an extra mile, given our historic reputation as a high-cost state (no longer accurate) to signal that we are competitive.
But for long-term job creation, Michigan needs more than a “business-friendly” tax and regulatory environment. We need strategic investment in Michigan’s assets that are the foundations of economic growth, and that the private sector doesn’t pay for: well educated people; strong, affordable universities driving innovation; clean lakes and rivers; modern transportation and communications infrastructure; cities with vibrant arts, culture, parks and libraries.
After years of an eroding tax base, these Michigan assets are severely degraded, inhibiting the state’s ability to promote itself abroad or keep our “home-grown” talent. Witness the $1+ billion transportation funding deficit named by Gov. Snyder in November, and recent press accounts showing Michigan’s great public universities being priced out of reach.
At a New Year’s party I was talking with a friend, a mergers and acquisitions financier from Detroit. She was bemoaning the decision (then just announced, now reversed, sort of) not to build Detroit’s light-rail line on Woodward, keeping Detroit once again from joining the party of modern global cities.
She said: “Why would Lydia (referencing my college-age daughter) want to stay here, when we can’t even find a way to pay for that?” Coming from her, a successful international businesswoman, unsolicited, was a powerful reminder we need assets like transit that lead and create economic development.
Michigan’s inability to support economy-shaping public goods is a function of both diminished tax receipts due to Michigan’s down-economy and an eroded tax base. We’ve lowered the personal income tax rate for 12 years, we’re now $8 billion below the Headlee tax limit, and we aren’t applying state sales tax to the growing two-thirds of our economy (services). It’s no wonder we can’t pay for roads and bridges, schools and teachers!
Leaders in other states are creatively tackling similar deficits. They’re passing dedicated revenue streams: $2.3 billion for university-led innovation under Ohio’s 3rd Frontier program, which has been evaluated to show a $10-1 ROI; Minnesota’s $6 billion over 25 years for water, parks and arts, through a Clean Water, Land, and Legacy Amendment. In California, unlikely bedfellows, including Google’s Eric Schmidt, Eli Broad, Condoleezza Rice and George Schultz, are part of the “Think Long Committee” behind a $10 billion ballot initiative for public investment. A similar effort, the “Bright Colorado” Initiative, would put new taxes to work specifically for education in that state.
Now we suddenly have a budget surplus in Michigan. In deciding what to do with it, we must remember: money talks. Budgets reflect our state’s priorities. When we spend more on prisons than universities, when we cut K-12 schools and water clean-up, while lowering business taxes, it speaks to what we do and don’t value.
To be sure, put a good chunk of this one-time budget surplus into the rainy day fund (it will rain again). But take the bulk of it, and put it into visible down-payments on important priorities for the future. At a minimum, Governor, I hope you will send a clear signal that your talk of providing help for teachers, rebuilding cities, keeping young people in Michigan and protecting our great universities was more than just that, talk.
To that end here are a few specific suggestions — informed by what competitors are doing — of where to invest this money:

  • $25 million for 10,000 Master Teachers (like North Carolina, which has 18,000 National Board Certified Master Teachers in classrooms, to Michigan’s 381)
  • $10 million for dual-enrollment high school early college credit taking (like Utah, which pays the bill for “Any Time, Any Place, Any Pace Learning”)
  • $10 million for early childhood investment, a commitment that just helped nine states, including (gulp) Ohio, win $500 million in federal Race-to-the-Top funds that Michigan lost out on (again).


  • $25 million state match for competitive R&D won by our universities (like Indiana, which rewards “success” with success)
  • $25 million for University-Innovation Centers, supporting advanced manufacturing and commercialization of new technologies (like (gulp) Ohio’s Edison Centers)
  • $25 million for performance-based bonuses for colleges that deliver improved outcomes (like over a dozen states, including (gulp) Ohio, that today have more affordable universities than Michigan).


  • $50 million into the state infrastructure bank for strategic transportation funding (like California’s I-Bank and dozens of other states’ programs), for Detroit light rail and other strategic priorities.


  • $25 million for Arts and Culture Funding (like Michigan invested when we were a national leader)
  • $40 million to jump-start urban redevelopment in core cities around anchor institutions like hospitals and universities (as Boston and New York City have done).


  • $15 million more for the “Pure Michigan” campaign (no one else has “Pure Michigan”)
  • $25 million for water cleanup (like Minnesota), to make “Pure Michigan” actually true!

There, we’ve just smartly invested $275 million…and we don’t just feel better, we will be better at creating jobs and growing incomes.
All evidence points to the richest states, with rising incomes, aren’t lowest-tax or highest in “business-friendly” rankings. Instead, they have the best educated people, functional infrastructure, and they leverage their special assets, like our great universities, historic cities, Great Lakes and outdoors.
Michigan can succeed by making a reality of great schools, great universities, functional cities people want to live in, and a “Pure Michigan” lifestyle that is real, not a marketing campaign. Let’s use this budget to send that message.
John Austin is president of the Michigan State Board of Education.

Leave a Reply

25 Comment threads
0 Thread replies
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
24 Comment authors
Find Out Morehow to create my own websitehow to build my own websitelenticular displayscheats diamonds Recent comment authors
newest oldest most voted
Notify of

Well, yeah, you have to spend money to make money. Education is It in this post industrial era; nothing else will suffice. One must provide adequate and hopefully enticing infrastructure to attract people; and the cops, courts, corrections system has to be addressed with progressive ideas and commitments. From whence this surplus really comes is inscrutible but here it is on paper anyway, Rick Snyder having made his point sort of. Detroit’s toothache is not painful enough yet -so they say – to schedule a dentist appointment but we ought at least to prepare a train route for that emergency.… Read more »

George Moroz
George Moroz

I agree with John’s investment advice. The State needs to invest in its unique sets of natural, cultural and heritage resources if it is to attract and retain the talent it needs now, and will need in the future. By “heritage resources,” I mean those things for which Michigan was once known and envied and which served as attractors for both talent and the inflow of capital. They include our educational system and the culture of innovation and entrepreneurialism that helped define our state as a frontier of opportunity offering the chance for both personal and collective prosperity. The one… Read more »

R Al Bain
R Al Bain

Budget surplus! What budget surplus? We owed the U.S. Treasury $3.2 billion for the unemployment trust fund so we sold bonds to the tune of $3.3 billion as to pay this off. So we increased our debt by $.1 billion. In understanding bonds, the seller of the bonds, the State of Michigan are the borrowers, with the buyers of these bonds as the lenders, how could we possibly have a surplus? If only I could use this same system of financial gimmicky as to pay-off my mortgage it would afford me the opportunity to stimulate Michigan’s economy!

Nonya Business
Nonya Business

So … Michigan digs itself into a hole by spending money hand over fist on do-nothing, feel-good programs which make administrators and liberal financiers happy (and rich) while the working citizens suffer and businesses flee to places not circling the drain. Thanks to the cutting of all these petty bureaucracies and projects, Michigan may actually realize a surplus. Time to bring back all the cool, hip sounding projects, says Mr. Austin. Let the kids in Detroit walk between burned out crackhouses; as long as little hip projects provide little enclaves of art and coolness for the financiers and elite power… Read more »


Spend 25 million for master teachers? The best and the brightest do not, and have not, gone into education. Where else can you have two master’s degrees and get paid half of what others in the private sector earn? Until teachers have opportunities for success like other professionals do, you’ll be attempting to make silk purses out of sows’ ears. You get what you pay for…and the smartest candidates stay away from the classroom.


[…] Austin, chair of the State Board of Education, in a Dome article lays out a more expansive public investment agenda in an article that provides ideas on how to use […]

Warren C. Gregory

Warren C. Gregory You would think that after so many harrowing years, Michigan lawmakers would begin to face its number one challenge—insufficient revenues to meet its growing needs. The state must do so quickly for time is running out. I recently completed a publication that compares Pennsylvania and Michigan, two states with a lot of similarities. In the past decade, each state took a different path in their struggle to achieve economic competitiveness. Pennsylvania followed an investment approach by heavily investing in its infrastructure. Not only did this investment make Pennsylvania’s infrastructure far better but, equally as important, it was… Read more »

edmonton seo company

177887 447602Thanks for the blog loaded with so numerous info. Stopping by your blog helped me to get what I was searching for. 485781

Check It Out Here

321679 861774I as effectively conceive so , perfectly indited post! . 700749

how to create my own website

126456 38498It can be tough to write about this subject. I feel you did an exceptional job though! Thanks for this! 141500

iphone screen protectors

474564 50931Aw, this was an exceptionally good post. In concept I would like to location in writing such as this moreover – spending time and actual effort to create a superb article

movers rates

40532 446877But a smiling visitant here to share the enjoy (:, btw excellent style and style . 658265

free online slots

881019 82873Effectively written articles like yours renews my faith in today

free slots no download

60546 789798i would have to make more christmas cards becuase next month is december already- 202106

truck rental services

527237 667906you

Hidemyass Pro

Brody February 21, 2014 at 2:40 am

turbulence training workout plan

427768 481694cool thanks for reis posting! btw are there feeds to your weblog? I

turbulence training scam

40678 907566Wow, awesome blog format! How long have you been blogging for? 640771

photographer in az

663031 837062This really is such a fantastic resource that you are offering and you supply out at no cost. I appreciate seeing web sites that realize the worth of offering a perfect valuable resource completely free of charge. I genuinely loved reading your submit. 362607

kan man träna för mycket

275113 368539Hey man, .This was an outstanding page for such a hard subject to talk about. I look forward to reading numerous much more fantastic posts like these. Thanks 608110

cheats diamonds

That is the best weblog for anybody who needs to seek out out about this topic. You notice a lot its virtually hard to argue with you (not that I really would want¡­HaHa). You definitely put a new spin on a topic thats been written about for years. Nice stuff, simply great!

lenticular displays

99189 880425Over and over again I think about these issue. As a matter of fact it was not even yesterday that I last thought about it. To be honest, what is your thought though? 837959

how to build my own website

28142 131739somehow located your web site when i was kind of stoned. excellent read 403626

how to create my own website

926121 18937Do you wear boxers or biefs? I wana bui em. 622109

Find Out More

Hey There. I discovered your blog the use of msn. This is a really smartly written article. I¡¯ll be sure to bookmark it and return to learn more of your useful info. Thank you for the post. I will definitely comeback.

Dome Magazine © 2022

Web Design by Douglas Marketing Group