Culture of Dark Money

By on December 20th, 2012

Columns
photo

Rich Robinson

Culture of Dark Money

December 21, 2012
The Huffington Post has reported that Macau casino magnate Sheldon Adelson actually spent $150 million in Campaign 2012, not the $100 million he had promised, or threatened. Adelson and his wife gave $54 million to committees that reported to the Federal Election Commission and spent the rest through 501(c)(4) social welfare organizations and (c)(6) business associations that didn’t report his contributions. He even managed to throw a million dollar stink-bomb at Debbie Stabenow through a boutique SuperPAC created just for the occasion.
In Michigan, 43 percent of the $18 million, eight-month television advertising campaign against the Obama administration and its policies was by sponsored by non-disclosing nonprofit corporations.
Michigan’s headline state candidate race was for our Supreme Court. In that campaign, the candidates raised and spent $3.4 million. The state political parties and a DC-based nonprofit corporation spent $11 million for television advertisements about the candidates in the last two months before Election Day. That television advertising wasn’t reported in the state campaign disclosure system. Those data are available from the public files of the state’s broadcasters and cable systems.
In the Michigan Supreme Court campaign, undisclosed outspent candidates, 3-1.
This is a big problem. Nobody has the motivation to spend big money in a judicial race like a litigant with a high-stakes case in the appeals pipeline. Imagine being in court opposing the person who financed the campaign of the justice who is going to decide your case. Imagine not knowing it, so you can’t make a legitimate motion for recusal. Dark money undermines the whole premise of judicial impartiality.
We are crazy to allow this cloud of dark money over our process for selecting justices.
Don’t take my word about this. The Judicial Selection Task Force chaired by Justice Marilyn Kelly and Senior Judge James L. Ryan of the U.S. Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals recognized the peril of dark money in judicial campaigns. Conservatives and progressives on that panel made a consensus recommendation that all spending in Michigan Supreme Court campaigns should be disclosed to its source.
In case you missed it, Michigan also had the most disgraceful trial court campaign in the country this year. Five incumbents, of mixed partisan roots, and two challengers running for the Sixth Circuit Court in Oakland County raised and spent $725,000. Two non-disclosing DC-based nonprofits, Americans for Job Security and Judicial Crisis Network, paid for a $2 million media campaign attacking one of the incumbents and touting the ‘plan’ of the two challengers, who claimed to know nothing about the dark money ads. The stealth campaign failed miserably.
Most informed observers believe this was a case of a troubled, angry rich guy behind a (c)(4) mask who didn’t like the way a previous judicial decision had gone in that court. You know, “I don’t like that decision. I’m going to take you out and I’m going to leave no fingerprints.”
How would you like to be running for a judgeship with our generous allowance for unaccountable spending? Would you stand up to an angry rich guy and risk a $2 million kneecapping by an anonymous assailant?
Governor Snyder keeps an active 527 committee called the Governor’s Club. Apparently our constitutional executives feel a 527 is necessary equipment. Jennifer Granholm, Mike Cox and Terri Land had 527s. Rick Snyder, Bill Schuette and Ruth Johnson have them now.
The Governor’s Club discloses its donors and its expenditures. Since Governor Snyder took office, it has raised $563,000. It’s been used for things like a communications consultant and hotel rooms at the Republican National Convention in Tampa.
The Governor also keeps a 501(c)(4) social welfare organization –New Energy to Reinvent and Diversify (NERD). It raised $1.3 million, just in 2011. We don’t know its donors, or its purpose, beyond “social welfare”. We haven’t seen yet how early legislative successes may have boosted NERD in 2012.
Why run a (c)(4) if you have a 527? The only difference is transparency. 527s disclose itemized receipts and expenditures; (c)(4)s don’t.
Dark money is baked into policy development, too. Many observers wonder who gave the Oxford Foundation the money to support the work of Richard McLellan as he developed a proposal for commercialization of public education. It would be rational for interest groups and individuals who are in the business of commercializing public education to support such a proposal, and if they did, citizens should know it. But we have no way to know whether those who stand to gain financially are the funders behind that proposal.
We are being swamped by a toxic wave of dark money. Accountability for the money driving our politics is withering.
Once upon a time, 10 years ago, the most strident political operative you knew would say, “Just let everybody spend as much as they want, and make them disclose it.”
Remember that?
These days everybody spends what they want, but a great amount, often a majority, is not disclosed. I can prove it. Dark money is proportionally bigger in Michigan politics than it is in national politics, Crossroads GPS and Americans for Prosperity notwithstanding.
I understand that we’re living with a political culture that accepts, even celebrates dark money. Most citizens don’t. As Justice Antonin Scalia once wrote, “Requiring people to stand up in public for their political acts fosters civic courage, without which democracy is doomed.”
If we citizens won’t demand real accountability for money in our politics, we are surrendering governance to the invisible hand of self-serving wealth. Let’s require those who think elections and public policy are just commodities for sale to show some civic courage along with their bankroll.
Rich Robinson is the executive director of the Michigan Campaign Finance Network. The opinions expressed here are his own, not necessarily those of his employer.

25
Leave a Reply

avatar
3000
25 Comment threads
0 Thread replies
0 Followers
 
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
25 Comment authors
cheats youtubehow to build my own websiteacrylic laminatelist building techniquesMake money fast online Recent comment authors
  Subscribe  
newest oldest most voted
Notify of
John H. Logie, Sr
Guest
John H. Logie, Sr

Spot on. Great job!

James Brazier
Guest
James Brazier

This dark moneyobscures accountability during political campaigns, especially the judicial ones. To call the judicial races nonpartisan in the face of huge amounts of dark money makes them covertly partisan. Michigan’ electorate has a record of being duped by big spending in its gubernatorial race of 2010 and its judicial races, especially the Supreme Court. While one would hope disclosure could eliminate deceptive campaigning, it appears to be judically protected free speech to be able to hide the identity of donors. Michigan has become the social laboratory for the political conservatives in winning over voters through deception and non-disclosure. Political… Read more »

Dick Baker
Guest
Dick Baker

Excellent – spot on

Peter Eckstein
Guest
Peter Eckstein

Apparently a PAC calling itself a “social welfare organization” can accept donations that are deductible contributions on one’s federal tax return. What a farce! I’m all for total disclosure of donors, but is it enough to let voters know that Sheldon Adelson donated X millions of dollars to a particular candidate or cause? Does a later report that Adelson supported some sleazy ad really erase the damage done by the ad itself? Why should being a rich casino owner give one man the ability to contribute a million times as much to campaigns than most ordinary voters can afford to… Read more »

Matt Marsden
Guest
Matt Marsden

Just curious as to how the organization that pays you is funded Mr. Robinson? Is is a C-Something group?

Bill Wortz
Guest
Bill Wortz

I agree with you Rich. If everyone would step to the line a declare in full light of day what they are doing in political giving and policy, the electorate would not be nearly as suspect. The people think anyone in politics are crooks. We could change this if we stopped hiding in the dark. Sunlight is the best policy for restoring confidence.

Rich Studley
Guest
Rich Studley

Once again Mr. Robinson targets most of his criticism at Republican office holders and conservative individuals or groups that exercise their constitutional right to free speech, while largely ignoring similar conduct by Democrats, unions, and personal injury attorneys. He is not the neutral political observer he pretends to be.

rar
Guest

It never fails to intrigue me that some politicians love “sunshine” laws until the sun is shining on their dubious practices . . . like fixing elections.

George Corsetti
Guest
George Corsetti

Informative article. The question is: How do we change Michigan’s campaign finance system?

Patrick L. Anderson
Guest

“Dark Money” is a problem. However, Sheldon Adelson is not the poster child here. You might recall he couldn’t get his chosen candidate nominated in the Republican party, let alone elected to office. We should be looking a little more broadly. For example, probably the biggest “social welfare” group to enter politics in US history was just announced: “Organizing for Action.” I’ll just excerpt a part of the [Jan 18] NPR story here: “Leading Organizing for Action is the [Obama] campaign’s brain trust: campaign manager Jim Messina, chief fundraiser Julianna Smoot and consultant David Axelrod, among others. It’s set up… Read more »

Watch Video Here
Guest

95254 742218You ought to experience a contest personally of the finest blogs on-line. I

http://www.tuttobatterie.com
Guest

52395 571720Admiring the time and effort you put into your web site and in depth info you offer. It

animal control nj
Guest

159315 578220An extremely interesting read, I may possibly not agree completely, but you do make some very valid points. 72374

rental in dc
Guest

564215 576948To know wisdom and instruction, to perceive the words of understanding 354497

free slot play with bonus
Guest

561263 369164I

best moving service
Guest

349804 830297Hey mate, .This was an superb post for such a hard topic to speak about. I appear forward to seeing several a lot more superb posts like this 1. Thanks 306632

canada online slots
Guest

614912 771024I like what you guys are up also. Such intelligent function and reporting! Maintain up the superb works guys I

turbulence training workout plan
Guest

589540 958936Thank you for sharing with us, I conceive this site genuinely stands out : D. 870550

scam busters
Guest

toward be preferred.

Read This
Guest

Hello there! I simply want to give you a huge thumbs up for your great info you have got right here on this post. I will be returning to your website for more soon.

Make money fast online
Guest

944415 692448the most common table lamp these days still use incandescent lamp but some of them use compact fluorescent lamps which are cool to touch.. 341829

list building techniques
Guest

468003 776889There is noticeably a bundle to learn about this. I assume you created positive excellent points in capabilities also. 15329

acrylic laminate
Guest

496614 983331I was searching for this. Actually refreshing take on the details. Thanks a whole lot. 302597

how to build my own website
Guest

706989 944792Paper rolls

cheats youtube
Guest

I am sure this post has touched all the internet people, its really really pleasant article on building up new webpage.


Dome Magazine © 2020

Web Design by Douglas Marketing Group